Michigan Ruggers hold honors in the Big Ten, the Midwest, and across the entire country. In 2018, Sequoyah Burke-Combs and Cole Van Harn became the first former players to play professionally, winning the inaugural MLR championship.
Big Ten
- George Janke, 2023, 1st Team 7s
- Shea Loughnane, 2023, 2nd Team 7s
- Colin Sampic, 2022, 2nd Team 15s
- Nathan Feldman, 2022, 2nd Team 7s
- George Janke, 2022, H.M. 7s
- Braden Loughnane, 2022 H.M. 7s
- Nathan Feldman, 2021, 2nd Team 15s
- Langston Sholl, 2021, 2nd Team 15s
- Jamie Demers, 2019, 1st Team 15s
- Jordan Perez, 2019, H.M. 15s
- Chening Duker, 2015 1st Team
- Matt Kasten, 2015 1st Team
- Sequoyah Burke-Combs, 2013, 1st Team
- Nick Fehrman, 2013, 1st Team
- Christian Mentzer, 2013, 1st Team
- Drew Vecchio, 2013, 2nd Team
- Cole Van Harn, 2013, 2nd Team
- Joel Conzelmann, 2013, 2nd Team
- Stuart Starkweather, 2013, H.M.
- Sequoyah Burke-Combs, 2012, 1st Team
- Drew Vecchio, 2012, 2nd Team
- Kenny Andutan, 2012, 2nd Team
- Joel Conzelmann, 2012, H.M.
- Mike LaCivita, 2012, H.M.
- Grady Bridges, 2012, H.M.
All-American
- Jamie Demers, 2019, All-American Camp Attendee
- Jamie Demers, 2018, All-American Camp Attendee
- Sequoyah Burke-Combs, 2015, USA Rugby 7s All-American H.M.
- Beau Brodtmann, 2008, American Rugby News All-American
- Greg Rose, 1982, All-American
USA Eagles
- John Hartman
- Dave Horton
- Rich Shurfeld
Major League Rugby
- Jamie Demers, 2023-Present, Seattle Seawolves
- Sequoyah Burke-Combs, 2018-2019, Seattle Seawolves
- Cole Van Harn, 2018-2019, Seattle Seawolves
Midwest
- Keith Bowen, Senior
- Ian Chapman, 1986, Senior
- Tom Foley, Senior, 7s
- Paul Leblanc, U21s
- Jeff Hagan, U21s, Senior, 7s
- Dave Horton, Senior
- Sean Knight, U25s, Senior, 7s
- Paul Lund, U25s
- Dan Mascellino, Senior
- John Moore, U25s
- Dave Perpich, Senior
- Greg Rose, Senior
- John Tayer, U21s
- Dale Tuttle, Senior
- Aaron Turk, 2005, Collegiate
- Karl Seibert, 2007, Collegiate, Senior
- Matt Trenary, 2011, Senior
- Dave Weber, Senior
- John Wooley, U25s
Academic
- Otto Janke, 2021-2022, NCR Scholastic All-American
- Shea Loughnane, 2021-2022, NCR Scholastic All-American
- Alex Olsen, 2021-2022, NCR Scholastic All-American
- Max Rector, 2021-2022, NCR Scholastic All-American
- Armen Vartanian, 2021-2022, NCR Scholastic All-American
- Sequoyah Burke-Combs, 2015, Academic All-American
- Nick Fehrman, 2015, Academic All-American
- Drew Vecchio, 2015, Academic All-American
- Karl Boothman, 2012, Academic All-American
Miscellaneous
- David Caputo, 2016, Penn Mutual Life of Significance Award
